Seeing versus hearing the poor
Did it not occur to the administration that, by trying so hard to make the poor unseen by foreign VIPs from their cars at last week’s summit of the Association of Southeast Asian Nations, it may have called more attention to the poverty problem instead (“Tinio: Poverty being concealed from Asean summit,” inquirer.net, 11/10/26)?
Was the bureaucracy not very confident about its statistical report last August, saying that the national poverty rate had already gotten to single-digit last year, and hence was very close to being eliminated (“Proportion of poor families reduced to 6.4 percent in 2025,” psa.gov.ph, 8/21/26)? In fact, for the National Capital Region (NCR) in particular, official poverty was put at only 0.6 percent of families. At the rate of only six of every thousand families, the poor in NCR should hardly be visible; why bother to hide them.
Listening to how much the people say was their income in terms of money is different from listening to what they say about being poor. In the first place, too much of the official threshold is based on the cost of food alone and too little is allowed for other consumption needs; in the second place, there’s no allowance for the necessary costs of earning the family’s income, such as commuting to work (see my “Unrealistic official poverty,” 9/26/26). The official threshold is set by the government, from above, without being tested by asking the people, at the bottom, how much they need.
The scale of poverty is radically different when one listens to the people themselves, as Social Weather Stations (SWS) does—see “Self-Rated Poverty rises by 9% to 55%, while Self-Rated Food Poverty rises by 8% to 44%, between June and September 2026,” www.sws.org.ph, 10/13/26. The entire population divides into three self-rated groups: the 55 percent Poor (P), plus 36 percent Not Poor (NP), and plus 9 percent Borderline (BL) who feel neither P nor NP but somewhere in-between. The BLs have become the smallest group, in the past few years. The Not Poor would obviously encompass both middle (M) and upper (U) classes, but dividing it between M and U is something I leave for future research.
There is an old-fashioned ABCDE system, originating in market research and still practiced, that classifies residences by outward appearance. It considers the security of the neighborhood, density of the homes, quality of construction materials, presence of a garden/garage, upkeep, etc. The As are rich; the Bs are upper-middle; the Cs are middle-class in the cosmopolitan sense; the Ds are the “masa”; and the Es are very poor who live in barong-barongs. The system is applied by interviewers, trained from photographs and field experience, and can be implemented even without entering the respondent’s home. But it is not (yet) standardized; every research outfit, including SWS, has its own house style.
As applied by SWS, I recall that many years ago the percentage of A and B combined (or AB) was about 5, that of C was 15, of D was 50, and of E was 30. Fairly soon we, and other researchers, began to use a combined ABC, since the field sample sizes got to be so small. But now—taking the SWS September 2026 national survey as a specific case—the ABC is less than 3 percent, the D has ballooned to 84 percent, and the E is down to 13 percent. This means there are now, relatively speaking, much fewer barong-barongs and residents of (gated) “villages.” In absolute terms, the national total of 30 million households is made up of some 1 million ABCs, 25 million Ds, and 4 million Es.
The ABCDE system and the Self-Rated Poverty system are consistent with each other. In the SWS survey of September 2026 in particular, the Self-Rated Poor are 29 percent of the ABC families, 54 percent of D families, and 67 percent of E families; these make up the national average of 55 percent Poor.
I do not worry that the substantial number of ABCs feeling Poor are misclassified; I suppose they have valid unfulfilled needs. Neither do I worry that the great number of Es claiming to be Not Poor have climbed above their proper station; I suppose they have good reason for contentment.
The Self-Rated Poverty (SRP) indicator system is scientific and practical, since it is both realistic and up-to-date. The next report on official poverty is expected in August 2028; it will refer to 2027, and will compare its findings to 2025 and earlier. By that time, SRP for December 2026, the four quarters of 2027 and the first two quarters of 2028 will be known and related to past experience.
There are three monkeys who say: hear no poverty, see no poverty, say nothing about poverty. Maybe, by ignoring it, poverty will go away?
—————-