What about American troops in Ayungin and Scarborough?
Q: What is required for an international agreement to be valid?
A: Section 21 of Article VII of the “Cory” (mother of President Aquino) Constitution says: “No treaty or international agreement shall be valid and effective unless concurred in by at least two-thirds of all the members of the Senate.”
Q: Is the Enhanced Defense Cooperation Agreement (Edca) constitutional?
Article continues after this advertisementA: Permit me to doubt. Section 25 of Article XVIII of the same Constitution says foreign “troops or facilities shall not be allowed in the Philippines except under a treaty duly concurred in by the Senate . . . and recognized as a treaty by the other contracting State.”
Q: How long will the Edca last?
A: Thereunder, initially for 10 years, but there is automaticity in extensions, so that my apo (the eldest is not quite six) may be affected.
Article continues after this advertisementQ: As a member of the Malevolent/Magnificent 12 who ended the more than 400 uninterrupted years’ presence of foreign troops in the country, you, RAV Saguisag, keep saying that Edca is a rotten egg, can you lay a better one?
A: Let me try. The American should be asked to return the Bells of Balangiga, now in Fort Warren, just outside of Cheyenne, with another in South Korea. These trophies are Catholic Church’s property in 1901. Then the Americans should be asked to put troops and facilities in Ayungin and Scarborough. We should be ready to die to the last American.
Q: We are weak; can we defend our territory alone?
A: It is a question of heart, as shown by the Vietnamese in defeating the French and the Americans. And the United States and Japan will help, if it would be in their national interests to do so. Edca or no Edca. No permanent friends or enemies, only permanent interests. Japan was our foe in World War II, when we were one huge military base of the United States. Japan successfully invaded us anyway.
Q: But, doesn’t Edca only implement our Mutual Defense Treaty of 1951?
A: MDT has been superseded by the 1987 Constitution and both our and American jurisprudence uphold the supersession theory.
—RENE A.V. SAGUISAG,
