Quantcast
Latest Stories

Margie Juico’s Pajero

By:

A few years ago, a Catholic bishop assigned to a Mindanao diocese resigned from his post for health reasons. The good bishop had a chronic back problem that was exacerbated by the performance of his duties. A bishop has to make what is known as a pastoral visit to all the parishes under his diocese, besides numerous other duties. He has to look after the social action programs being implemented. In Mindanao, most dioceses have a very active program for indigenous peoples. Few people in Manila perhaps have knowledge of the vast Mindanao terrain where the hinterlands can only be traversed on unpaved roads.

As an anthropologist, I myself have to traverse some of these roads. One community I visit regularly is only about 40 kilometers from the main highway in Bukidnon. But it takes me two hours to reach the village over the most mercilessly unpaved roads with humps that can put a camel’s back to shame. There is also another village I regularly visit where no bridge spans the river known for its very unpredictable current. Just the other day, a friend’s Toyota 4×4 vehicle was swept by the strong currents after a downpour.

That bishop had to eventually resign. His work was, literally, back-breaking. Not even a 4×4 vehicle could alleviate the pain he was suffering. His resignation was accepted by the Pope.

Distance and the primitiveness of roads are a reality in Mindanao that Margie Juico of the Philippine Charity Sweepstakes Office surely does not know. I wonder now if she can sleep well at night. She has just committed one of the most serious blunders a public servant can ever do—to accuse and impute malice where there was none.

I have reviewed the video of her media interview several times over. She now says she never mentioned “Pajero.” But she did. And for saying that, she was able to successfully create a media fiesta that vilified innocent people. Face the consequences and pay her debts she now must do. A wrong had been done. The bishops have paid a very dear price. But Margie Juico is scot-free.

There is a serious question that is now raised about media ethics. One blogger said it well: Manila media “have practically made a livelihood of libel and defamation, and nobody gives a hoot. This is a signal to revisit what is right and what is wrong.”

“People yak so much about human rights, forgetting that in natural norms that govern human relations, every person—even a wrongdoer—has a right to a good name; in Civil Law, it is called personal ‘honor’.”

Margie Juico and her husband Philip were once active members of the Ang Ligaya ng Panginoon community. A few years ago, however, the family name surfaced in media when a son who was councilor in Quezon City authored that city’s reproductive health ordinance. What has happened to the catholicity of that family?

It is difficult to believe what she had done was a routine administrative matter. The coincidences are too glaring to ignore. Besides, the Commission on Audit report did not mention anything about a “Pajero.” We know, however, that just a few weeks ago, Bishop Juan de Dios Pueblos made a very scathing criticism against the Noynoy Aquino government. Was it eureka that Margie stumbled upon the PCSO records of the bishop’s letter requests? She must be a lucky person. Bring down Pueblos to his knees. Margie did it successfully for Noynoy Aquino.

A columnist of another paper narrated from a reliable newspaper source that Margie Juico “had dinner with the editorial staff of one anti-Church newspaper a week or so before the propaganda attack on the bishops started. They reportedly agreed to ‘teach the bishops a lesson’ for campaigning vehemently against the reproductive health bill.”

The aim was to stop the switch of support from the pro-RH and undecided camps to the anti-RH camp. And the modus operandi was to bring down the moral standing of the bishops, the columnist narrated. Not long after that, the “Pajero bishops” came into the news. It was then at Juico’s behest that Sen. TG Guingona, ever the Malacañang lackey, decided to investigate the bishops. Guingona reportedly visited Juico at the PCSO prior to the hearings. If true, this is another violation of established ethical norms. Everything appears to have been facilitated, made worse by an inept reading of the Constitution.

Now it appears that the whole fiasco was facilitated by a PR firm, Eon Stakeholder Relations, to the tune of P544,400 which Sen. Jinggoy Estrada uncovered. Juico’s ambivalent denials seem to suggest she was caught off guard. The PCSO had just denounced what their predecessors did. Now they practice what they had denounced. It is a case of “Tama na, sobra na, kami na naman.” And that is President Aquino’s “matuwid na daan” for you.

Margie Juico was Cory Aquino’s most faithful lieutenant. Perhaps she still remembers that Cory was besieged by nine coup attempts. Each time, the Catholic Church came to her rescue. Perhaps she can still vividly recall that it was Cardinal Sin who sounded the call for people to mass at Edsa. I’m sure she remembers that it was Cardinal Sin who would update the Filipinos on the jailed Sen. Ninoy Aquino.

Precisely we elected Noynoy Aquino as president because of the awe and reverence that the country has for Cory Aquino, painted largely in part by the Catholic Church. One writer exclaimed: “Now that Noynoy is the President, he has the gall to shame the bishops. For what? Just to show that he is clean and that the bishops are dirty?”

Margie’s Malacañang operation is a success. They have just gained the whole world.

* * *

Comments to antonmonta@gmail.com


More from this Column:

Recent Stories:

Complete stories on our Digital Edition newsstand for tablets, netbooks and mobile phones; 14-issue free trial. About to step out? Get breaking alerts on your mobile.phone. Text ON INQ BREAKING to 4467, for Globe, Smart and Sun subscribers in the Philippines.

Tags: back breaking duties , Bishop Juan de Dios Pueblos , Catholic bishop , Eon Stakeholder Relations , Margie juico , Mindanao diocese , Pajero bishops , Philippine Charity Sweepstakes Office , Sen. Jinggoy Estrada

Disclaimer: The comments uploaded on this site do not necessarily represent or reflect the views of management and owner of INQUIRER.net. We reserve the right to exclude comments that we deem to be inconsistent with our editorial standards.
  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_SOEVHIPPMHMHREOUIVH75FIVUE leonardoo

    I think you are not helping the church by trying to go into offensive in justifying Delos Pueblos blatant disregard of propriety as a man of cloth. The impropriety of writing a letter to ask specifically a SUV as a birthday gift and in return a promise to support the  political leader cannot be denied. Hardly will the Filipino masses  
    believe that Bishops need expensive SUVs for frequent trips to far-flung areas to serve the spiritual needs of the poor and to provide charity. Provide CHARITY? FALSE. MAYBE IN REAR OCCASSION SOME CHURCH DO, BUT MOST OFTEN THE CHURCH ASK DONATIONS/CHARITY FROM ITS FLOCKS.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_O2P6DLGPDZN6T6QS53FV5XY4VQ angele

    Mrs. Juico’s retraction and apology regarding the use of the term Pajero is too late and insincere. The damage has been done. The term Pajero connotes extravagance and luxury. Rina Jimenes, in her column, criticized the bishops for not requesting less expensive vehicles. But when the truth came out, critics of the bishops said it does not matter what type of car. It matters because it raises doubts on Mrs. Juico’s credebility, and whether she is making this expose in good faith.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_PK4EXNYMJIE4HH423MFAIWIB6I dodo

    i been reading opinion regarding our bishops “error of judgement”. Many defends the bishops. When bishops came out of the senate hearing, they proudly proclaim that they were vindicated. But by whom? By God or by the likes of Ms Santiago and Jinggoy, It is not the issue of the “things” asked or given… but the issue was CORRUPTION. “The rich rule over the poor, and the borrower is servant to the lender (Prov 22:7)”. What then was given back to Gloria by these bishops? Who was that bishop who told PNoy to resign?

  • http://twitter.com/msmeeshee Mithi Villarmea

    I don’t like reading this author. He’s turning a blind eye as to what is happening. Anti-Catholic church nonsense. Seriously. Are we in the Medieval Period?

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_CJK5EJX52XKXLTVGUF2YXDBKFY Podpod Salipod

    DAPAT MATUTO RIN ANG MGA OBISPO!!!

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_CJK5EJX52XKXLTVGUF2YXDBKFY Podpod Salipod

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_CJK5EJX52XKXLTVGUF2YXDBKFY Podpod Salipod

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_2RS6BHPPB43X5L5IA42KF7W52I Huey

    pAJERO RO NOT STILL THE BISHOPS WITH ALL THEIR SOUNDRY AND HYPOCRISY ARE ASKING MONEY FROM aRROYO. WE CAN NOT UNDO THAT. THOSE BISHOPS AS GUILTY AS SIN WHEN CAUGHT. JUICO HAS NOTHING TO DO ABOUT THIER COMMITTED ACTS OF SIN AND BETRAYAL OT TURST BY THE CATHOLIC MEMEBRS WHO BELIEVE THIER VOW OF POVERTY. I DON’T BELIEVE THEIR EXPLANATION ABOUT USING IT FOR THE POOR. BISHOPS ARE LIVING IN LUXURY IN THEIR PALACES WHILE THE CATHOLIC MEMBERS ARE DONATING MONEY EVERY SUNDAY. THE SEVEN ARE THE EXAMPLE OF THE CHURCH OF 19TH CENTURY..THE LIKES OF FATHER DAMASO.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_FN3D4W6RMVV7LI6ORL3YUZOBSY Vincent

    This author is clearly right-wing, faaaaaaaaaaaaar right. He is also proud for over-estimating pacquiao’s capabilities as a politician and an intellectual. 

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_2RS6BHPPB43X5L5IA42KF7W52I Huey

    A PIECE OF ADVICE FOR THE CLERGY: FATHER BERNAS, ONE OF THE BRILLIANT CONSTITUTIONALISTS WHO WAS AMONG WHO FRAMED THE 1986 CONSTITUTION SHOULD BE CONSULTED WHENEVER THEY WANT TO ASK MONEY FROM THE GOVERNMENT. THE SEPARATION OF STATE AND CHURCH IS EMBODIED IN THE CONSTITUTION , THEREFORE, NO FUNDS FROM THE GOVERNEMTN SHOULD BENEFIT THE CHURCH WHETHER IT IS FOR THE WELFARE OF THE POOROR CHARITY AND BESIDES THOSE BISHOPS ARE NOT THE ONE DOING THE FIELD WORK. THE  WORK FOR SOCIAL ACTION IS ALWAYS DONE BY THE PARISH PRIEST. JUICO SHOULD NOT HAVE MADE AN APOLOGY AND WHAT DAMAGE IS DONE TO THE BISHOPS WHEN THEIR SU[PPORT  OF THE ARROYO HAS DONE THE DAMAGE LONG BEFORE THEY ARE EXPOSED.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_KPQZT55YRHS2UXLWDYJRQW4EYA Ma. Elena

    The low intensity conflict, “to divide and rule” ! Nakita  ng kalaban ang lakas ng Simbahang Katoliko at the time of the Edsa 1 (Revolution). The enemy (evil) will try to destroy the faithful ones, but the Catholic faith was built upon the ROCK OF PETER, in (2Cor12:8-9) “My grace is sufficient for you, for power is made perfect in weakness.” God knows our human weaknesses. The Lord is ever patient with us. It is beyond our human understanding, He will be the final Judge!

  • Anonymous

    Out of bias or prejudice or bigotry, comments against the Catholic Church in the Philippines almost always turn virulent but without rational basis.  Charity and tolerance should be the flavor of the month, not hate, anti-clericalism, destructive free-thinking and atheism.  Maybe it is best to study the Church well and not be swept away by skepticism, cynicism and hopelessness.  Man is fragile and can err and God alone is the judge of all.  The position of the Church against legalizing artificial contraceptive methods is founded on morality, ultimately in the Natural Law which decrees that for every human act, a moral responsibiliy is inseparably bound: if towards the good, then it is moral. Human sexuality is not an illness or a disease.  Human intervention, surgical or medical, is only prescribed because of a disease, to cure it.  There is nothing to cure in the case of human sexuality. If intercourse is made during the fertile period of the woman, ovulation or fertilization may happen; during the infertile period of the woman during reproductive age or during active breast feeding, no fertilization is possible.  Observing this natural ryhthm by any NATURAL FAMILY PLANNING METHODS that are more safe, reliable and inexpensive to effectively space the number of children in the family is in accordance with the Natural Law.  Artificial contraceptive methods (mechanical, surgical/medical, chemical) are against the natural order and  natural design of the integrity of sex, love, marriage and the family.  Please read the encyclical “Caritas in Veritate” or browse through Radio Veritas 846 for a comprehensive treatment of the social doctrine of the Church.

  • http://pulse.yahoo.com/_7V5WZKLXIXCD2V2M3YO5FUEXXA RadcalPrince

    The thing is, do not impute that all the bishops are living in luxury or not practicing their vows of poverty just because they are using an expensive vehicle, especially when they use to to go to far-flung areas where the roads are tougher than a rock. just because the Catholic Church and it’s leaders don’t take revenge on their critics don’t give you the right to malign every one for the fault of a few misguided leaders. And if you think the bishops are living in luxury, what about the leaders of various Christian denominations like Mike Velarde? Are they not multimillionaires, even billionaires? And where are the “critics” who’s so called “objectivity” make them villify the bishops and the church leaders in the media? If these critics (of which i must presume you belong) are really after the truth and justice, then why don’t you speak out against these other people? or don’t you think you are only attacking the bishops and the Catholic hierarchy because you know precisely that the teaching of Christ protects you from revenge? these leaders don’t stoop to lower levels of morality just to defend themselves. it takes a more open minded person to understand these things, and i guess at the moment you are not open minded enough because you have too much bias against the Church.



Copyright 2011 . All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed. To subscribe to the Philippine Daily Inquirer newspaper in the Philippines, call +63 2 896-6000 for Metro Manila and Metro Cebu or email your subscription request here.
Factual errors? Contact the Philippine Daily Inquirer's day desk. Believe this article violates journalistic ethics? Contact the Inquirer's Reader's Advocate. Or write The Readers' Advocate:
c/o Philippine Daily Inquirer Chino Roces Avenue corner Yague and Mascardo Streets, Makati City, Metro Manila, Philippines Or fax nos. +63 2 8974793 to 94
Advertisement

News

  • At least 33 killed in Iraq attacks
  • Arroyo hopes gov’t will uphold rule of law, laments campaign vs Arroyos
  • An eyewitness or Justice Sereno testifying could save prosecution, says Santiago
  • Senate junks De Lima’s testimony as hearsay
  • Honasan to prosecution: Tell court your plans to avoid ‘unpleasant surprises’
  • Sports

  • Westbrook, Durant power Thunder past Celtics
  • Jeremy Lin to miss dunk moment but will fill bookshelves
  • Pacquiao ‘embarrassed’ by Mayweather offer
  • Manny Pacquiao swept up in Linsanity
  • Don’t wait for P-Noy to save boxing
  • Lifestyle

  • PF Chang’s first Asian branch opens–to long wait lists
  • ‘Tikuron or tikoy turon’
  • Oriental Citrus Salad, Herb Pan-fried Fish–Mama Maimee, it’s good ol’ comfort food!
  • Burrata Cheese Ravioli, Burger with Foie Gras, ‘snowball tiramisu’–chow time in Hong Kong
  • ‘Udang Goreng Chilli Garam’ (Chili Prawns)–a Peranakan favorite
  • Entertainment

  • Sepia-tinted statuettes? Oscar films look to past
  • ‘Bourne’ star leaves ‘legacy’ in Palace visit
  • Through the years …
  • As Pinoy as the jeepney
  • Modern-day superhero
  • Business

  • Oil prices lower on weak Europe, China data
  • No change in PSE index
  • Again, oil firms up prices
  • PPP schools project attracts 15 firms
  • Surging crude oil prices worry BSP
  • Technology

  • US attorneys general pressure Google on privacy
  • Company sues Apple over iPad name in Shanghai
  • Megaupload founder Kim Dotcom released on bail
  • New York taxis could get iPads—report
  • Google under fire for sidestepping track-blocking software
  • Opinion

  • Editorial cartoon, February 23, 2012
  • Wisdom, not legality
  • People power
  • The algorithm of kindness
  • ‘Medicare portability’ for Fil-Ams
  • Global Nation

  • Philippine Immigration issues reminder on annual reporting of aliens
  • Okay to buy warships but don’t bring US into Spratly dispute
  • Ibuna lawyer: Aleli not Ignacio Arroyo’s legal wife due to technicality
  • Government lifts ‘au pair’ ban to Europe
  • Former Pagcor chief denies getting gifts from Okada
  • Marketplace
    Advertisement
    © Copyright 1997-2011 INQUIRER.net | All Rights Reserved