Quantcast

Afterthoughts

No EDSA in Cairo

By

During those heady Tahrir Square days in the spring of 2011, many of us thought—or hoped—the Egyptian uprising would turn out to be another EDSA Revolution, a triumph of democracy, a glittering example of successful non-violent political change.  For those of us who had participated in different ways in the struggle to overthrow Ferdinand Marcos decades ago, there was a nice feeling of “déjà vu all over again,” to borrow Yankee catcher Yogi Berra’s immortal phrase.

Over two years later, Egypt preoccupies us once more, and our thoughts are likely to be depressing ones.  There is really something dreadfully wrong with this military-led alliance of Mubarak supporters, secularists, and oppositionists that deposed the democratically elected Morsi government.

True, the Morsi government exhibited authoritarian predilections, but respect for the rules of the democratic game is usually not something innate but one that is forced by the rough and tumble of struggles that unfold in both parliament and the “parliament of the streets.”

In the case of the Philippines, for instance, it took nearly a quarter of a century after the EDSA Uprising for the extreme left and the extreme right to be socialized to the rules of representative democracy, and the process remains incomplete.

Democracy is a learning experience, and it was the cut and thrust of democratic competition that could have led to a pluralist democratic system that was cut short by the same military that sustained Mubarak.

The events in Egypt lead us to ask the hard question of where, over two years after it broke out, the Arab Spring is headed.  For the bloom is off the rose almost everywhere, with the assassination of key opposition leaders in Tunisia, the collapse of the central state in Libya, and the unending civil war in Syria, the cost of which has now exceeded 100,000 lives.

One may wonder whether with all the violence, sufferings, and interventions it has unleashed, the Arab democratic uprising is worth it.  Has it not opened a Pandora’s Box, the bad things from which outweigh the good?  That western neoconservatives and Zionists answer in the affirmative is not surprising since these cultural chauvinists believe that owing to their being a western outpost in an Arab sea, only Israelis are capable of democratic rule.  But often, when confronted with this question, even liberals and progressives are paralyzed.

Confronted with these troubling questions, it is probably useful to take a comparative perspective and the long view.

With respect to violence and human rights violations, democratic transitions that are bloody far outnumber those that are peaceful.

As Barrington Moore reminds us in The Social Origins of Dictatorship and Democracy, the English transition to democracy, which is often mistakenly presented as a case of peaceful evolution, was a violent one that involved numerous deaths in a civil war, including the beheading of a king, Charles I, in the seventeenth century. And as Arno Mayer so vividly documents in his opus The Furies, The French Revolution, the classic democratic transition, saw the interplay between revolutionary Terror and Counterrevolutionary Terror that took thousands of lives over a chaotic five-year period.

But after the violence, after the bloodshed, will democracy ultimately prevail?   Revolutions have their ebbs and flows, and it does seem like the solidity of the institutions that emerge are built on the inevitable struggles that the democratic revolution unleashes.   In this regard, the French revolutionary democratic process that began in 1789 can only be said to have been firmly consolidated with the Third Republic from 1870 to 1940.

In between, the country saw counterrevolution, Napoleon’s imperial government, the revolution of 1830, the revolution of 1848, the Second Empire, and the Paris Commune.  Much like France’s experience, many democratic transitions are like a dance with several movements, consisting of two steps forward and one step back, but the overall direction is forward.

Closer to our time, the Latin American experience is instructive.  Thousands perished in the resistance to dictatorships in the 1970’s and 1980’s, with some 30,000 in Argentina alone.

The authoritarian regimes were overthrown in the early eighties, but the democracies that emerged were subverted in the late eighties and nineties by regimes dominated by elites backed by the International Monetary Fund that imposed poverty-creating structural adjustment programs in the 1990’s.

By the first decade of the 21st century, however, people throughout Latin America had had enough of elite democracies.

People’s movements produced new populist and more participatory democracies that supplanted elite democracies in Venezuela, Bolivia, and Ecuador, and neoliberal economic regimes were dismantled in these countries as well as in Brazil and Argentina.

The democratic revolution had its advances and retreats, but the strategic thrust of the process was forward, towards democratic deepening and consolidation.

Indeed, the sharper and more protracted the struggle, the more firm, it seems, are the foundations of the democracy that emerges.

The Arab democratic revolution will have its ebbs and flows, but, taking the long view, it is likely that the omega point of the Arab Spring will be the institutionalization and consolidation of democratic forms and practices that will have their own unique features and dynamics.

What we may be witnessing is simply the end of Act I of the democratic revolution in the Middle East.

*Walden Bello is representative of the party Akbayan in the House of Representatives of the Philippines.


Follow Us


Follow us on Facebook Follow on Twitter Follow on Twitter


More from this Column:

Recent Stories:

Complete stories on our Digital Edition newsstand for tablets, netbooks and mobile phones; 14-issue free trial. About to step out? Get breaking alerts on your mobile.phone. Text ON INQ BREAKING to 4467, for Globe, Smart and Sun subscribers in the Philippines.

Short URL: http://opinion.inquirer.net/?p=58777

Tags: Arab Spring , Cairo , democracy , Edsa Revolution , Egypt , Morsi government , People Power , politics

  • GMGUERRERO

    OH YEAH? WHAT DID EDSA BRING TO THE FILIPINO PEOPLE?

    • HoyGago

      Freedom to post stupid comments.

  • ConnieLee90

    The EDSA Revolution as “glittering example of successful non-violent political change.” The only reason why the EDSA Revolution turned out to be a successful non-violent political change was because of FM himself. Though I much opposed the puny dictator and his dictatorship, in the final analysis, he also had a soft heart and could not stomach the wholesale slaughter of his people. Remember that it was FM who in the final moments before his retreat, restrained the urges of Favian Ver to engage in bloodbath, thus saving possibly thousands from sure death and preventing slide into further chaos.

    • novaliches

      100% agreed. If FM was not the president at that time, hundred/thousand may had died. with some guys putting peoples in harms way, while they hide. if we had Assad or like as president,

  • rodben

    NO EDSA IN CAIRO… Just because Macoy loves Poor Pinoys if the elite organizers who finance a big money on that event did not pay the poor Pinoy plus a very sweet promises just to join the EDSA.. and if all the people in EDSA are just elitista and oppositions surely same2 like CAIRO REAL REVOLUTION.. and until now still Marcoses in Malacanang and surely no abusive Porbes billionaires in Pinas and the masses are not going to become OFW just to have food in table.

  • oh_noh

    no EDSA? great!!!

    EDSA = CROCS!!!

  • Pork_Republik

    People Power really? As what I understand its just a power struggle between a strongman and the Philippines oligarchy with the Filipino people as the pawns.

  • pepito gwaps

    No EDSa for barbaric leaders. At China, they used machine gun to disperse protesting citizens at Tianenmen square.

  • kismaytami

    EDSA revolution as triumph of democracy… Nope, it’s the biggest blunder in history of democracy. EDSA revolution is a clear example of how the elite class can manipulate the poor with flowery promises that turns out to be self serving, and keep on manipulating them. In case of EDSA revolution, the poor class was screwed not just once, but twice.

    • slicenziuten

      maybe edsa-1 is not immune to accusations of being driven by the elite class, nonetheless macoy was out and so was his corrupt/ dictatorship rule.

  • mike8232

    EDSA is a farce look at where we are now as a country. EDSA is nothing to be proud of. We went from one dictator to hundreds of corrupt leaders.

    • wanluna

      so you think that we will be better off if EDSA didnt happen?

      • novaliches

        EDSA make the country worst, unless you are a die hard yellow. Just ask the old citizens, who lived during the marcos era and can truthfully state the conditions before compare to current, without bias.

      • wanluna

        well i dont know about you but i lived a part of the marcos era, and i can tell you it really seems nice but NOT. and those old people that you are referring to, they are quite lucky they didnt experience the oppression of a dictator and his family and minions, who until now can fool some people to believe everything is much better in their hands.

  • txtman SUPOTiful Bading

    FIRE IN CAIRO!

    -ROBERT SMITH OF THE CURE

  • novaliches

    EDSA gave us false hope, that the crocs were gone, the problem is people were misled. The real crocs were the ones that stayed behind.

    • pepito gwaps

      EDSA is a breakthrough but the previous leaders fail to secure the constitution from flaws specially in handling public funds, fighting corruptions and enforcement of the laws.



Copyright © 2014, .
To subscribe to the Philippine Daily Inquirer newspaper in the Philippines, call +63 2 896-6000 for Metro Manila and Metro Cebu or email your subscription request here.
Factual errors? Contact the Philippine Daily Inquirer's day desk. Believe this article violates journalistic ethics? Contact the Inquirer's Reader's Advocate. Or write The Readers' Advocate:
c/o Philippine Daily Inquirer Chino Roces Avenue corner Yague and Mascardo Streets, Makati City, Metro Manila, Philippines Or fax nos. +63 2 8974793 to 94
Advertisement
Advertisement

News

  • UN warns banana fungus spreading from Southeast Asia
  • Massive infra spending set
  • ‘No real progress in PH if dynasties not dismantled’
  • Cardinal Tagle to faithful: Join politics to clean it
  • Our Lady of Piat: Centerpiece of Cagayan’s gifts to Christianity
  • Sports

  • Federer would skip tennis to be with wife, newborn
  • Manny Pacquiao in PBA? If so, he’ll wear No. 17
  • PSC sets Blu Girls US training
  • Power Pinoys settle for 7th place
  • Successful coaches to get raise
  • Lifestyle

  • ‘Labahita a la bacalao’
  • This is not just a farm
  • Clams and garlic, softshell crab risotto–not your usual seafood fare for Holy Week
  • Moist, extra-tender blueberry muffins
  • The truffled mac ‘n’ cheese, eggs benedict, chicken leg confit are excellent
  • Entertainment

  • Why Lucky has not bought an engagement ring for Angel
  • Derek more private with new girlfriend
  • ‘Community’ star happy with return of show’s creator
  • Jealousy is kid stuff
  • Mommy-daughter adventure continues
  • Business

  • PH presses bid to keep rice import controls
  • PSEi continues to gain
  • Number of retrenched workers rose by 42% in ’13
  • PH seen to sustain rise in FDIs
  • Gov’t subsidies to state firms fell in first 2 months
  • Technology

  • Smart phone apps and sites perfect for the Holy Week
  • Tech company: Change passwords or suffer ‘Heartbleed’
  • Filling the digital talent gap
  • SSS to shut down website for Holy Week
  • Another reason to quit social media this Holy Week: your safety
  • Opinion

  • Editorial cartoon, April 17, 2014
  • A humbler Church
  • Deepest darkness
  • ‘Agnihotra’ for Earth’s health
  • It’s the Holy Week, time to think of others
  • Global Nation

  • First Fil-Am elected to Sierra Madre, Calif. city council
  • UC Irvine cultural night to dramatize clash of values in immigrant family
  • Filipino sweets and info served at UC Berkeley Spring Fest
  • Milpitas, California kids wrap up a successful run of ‘The Wiz’
  • Netizens welcome Japan’s visa-free travel plan
  • Marketplace