Editorial

Reverberations

A+
A
A-

Many of the victims were visitors, convention delegates from around the country. Perhaps that is why the blast that shook Cagayan de Oro and killed eight persons and injured 46 others at a popular nightspot last Friday continues to reverberate. It struck—it still jangles—a common nerve. A week since the tragic incident, however, we still don’t know who did it, and why it was done. This silence from the investigating agencies is almost deafening.

Aside from those two essential questions, others also need to be asked. Here are three related sets.

First: Two days after the bombing, Interior Secretary Mar Roxas noted that the explosive “was really different because it did not have shrapnel… or metal parts like in grenades or claymore mines.” The physicians who prepared the autopsy report had not found any. “In other words, the bomb was not a mortar round or an artillery round, which was set off by a detonator, because no metal parts were recovered. It did not contain nails, glass shards or metal balls, which are usually placed inside a bomb to hurt people.”

Why, then, did the officer in charge of the Army’s 4th Infantry Division, based in Cagayan de Oro itself, say initial investigation showed that a mortar round had been used? Perhaps we can attribute Brig. Gen. Ricardo Visaya’s statement to initial confusion. But where did his sense of certainty come from? “It is made of mortar but we cannot say what type of mortar, and the investigators are trying to determine if it’s a 60mm or an 80mm type of mortar and they are evaluating the fragments recovered,” he said the day after the bombing. Then he added, in a mix of Filipino and English: “This is the style we usually get from armed Moro rebels in the past, but it’s not fair to attribute this to any rebel group.”

Turns out it was not fair at all to declare the bomb was a mortar round; what was Visaya’s purpose in his passive-aggressive raising of the Moro scare?

Second: Early in July, the Canadian, Australian and American embassies issued adverse travel alerts, advising their citizens not to travel to any part of Mindanao. The US travel advisory included the cities of Davao, General Santos and Cagayan de Oro, even though these areas were seen as “generally more controlled.” It also noted that “US Embassy employees must receive special authorization from embassy security officials to travel to any location in Mindanao and the Sulu archipelago, including these urban centers.”

Did the perpetrators behind the July 26 bombing show up on the US security radar? While it is only right that the Philippine government should protest blanket travel advisories that cover inordinately large areas (“any location in Mindanao”?), it is also only prudent for the Department of the Interior and Local Government to reconsider the basis of the travel alerts and request the three embassies for a briefing.

Third: Despite Cagayan de Oro’s longstanding reputation for being safe, the heavy hand of violence has visited the popular convention city from time to time. Perhaps unknown or unremembered by many, two mysterious blasts shook the city late last year.

On Oct. 11, 2012, two bombs were found outside Maxandrea Hotel near Cogon Market. The second bomb was defused, but the first exploded, killing two civilians and wounding two of the policemen who had responded to the early morning call to investigate an unusual package.

On Nov. 21, a grenade attached to the door of a financing company exploded when the firm opened for business, wounding eight victims, including two policemen who happened to be passing by at the exact moment of detonation.

What has happened to the official investigation into these incidents? Even more important: Do they have any clues to offer about the July 26 bombing? At the time, sketchy reports suggested that the Oct. 11 blast did not involve mortar rounds either.

But even if the 2012 bombings have nothing to do with the big one last Friday, the state of the investigation into the incidents or the lack of resolution in the cases still bears important consequences. Are the police in the city up to the job (and deserving of the city’s enviable reputation for general safety)? Are certain groups using the traditional openness of the city to test new modes of attack?

The 2012 bombings quickly faded from national consciousness, in part because the victims were the city’s own residents. We hope that the national attention that is now focused on Cagayan de Oro will help solve the mystery, not only of the bombing last Friday, but also of the explosions last year.

Disclaimer: The comments uploaded on this site do not necessarily represent or reflect the views of management and owner of INQUIRER.net. We reserve the right to exclude comments that we deem to be inconsistent with our editorial standards.

  • Gerald Abueva

    A failure of intelligence by PNP.
    Not intelligent at all, Mr. Visaya.

  • mad_as_Hamlet

    * * * * * * *
    If one is interested in these matters, one should go back in time.
    Back to 2002, May 16. Back to Davao City.
    Back to a hotel room in Evergreen Hotel.
    When an “American-British” national named Michael Meiring
    suffered very serious injuries. Because of an explosion.

    The aftermath and what the US government did are not fiction.
    Research, read, and reflect.

    The “reverberations” today could have started from yesterday.
    But that they are, at the very least, “inspired” from things
    in the past is also not fiction.
    – – -

  • ddano

    Learn from the Boston Marathon Bombings.

  • joni_depp

    The root of this is the one-sided Bangsamoro agreement entered into by Malacañang and the MILF. Government negotiators caved in to the MILF and alienated almost all other stakeholders. Hence disgruntlement. And more chaos in the future.

  • Fulpol

    CDO is a friendly city.. I traveled to this place a couple of times..

    couple of years, the Kato group spread terror in Iligan City, a neighboring city of CDO.. CDO is quite far from Iligan City.. Iligan City is part of Lanao del Norte.. a neighboring province of Muslim dominated province of Lanao del Sur..

    the military recently has confrontation with Kato group called BIFF.. if they were able to spread terror in Iligan City in the past, is there a possibility that they can extend it to CDO by using bomb?

    but again, PDI is refuting the AFP General in trying to insinuate the Moro rebel has something to do about the bombing..

    US Dept. of State issued a travel advisory.. did they know something about a possible form of attack to major cities in Mindanao, even mentioning a friendly city of CDO (why not Iligan City) far from ARMM provinces?

    Malacanang, Mar Roxas and media should be careful in handling this issue.. a major territorial dispute might occur in Mindanao in the future if this issue is not handled well..

  • TANYA22

    Meaning
    that we do not have a reputation in terms of Security Intelligence, that our
    Government is very lacks for our Security and come what may if something
    happened. Should we always wait that these barbaric should happen? I think each
    Municipal should also have some staffs that would be responsible for the
    Security Intelligence surveillance and this is should be round the clock. Even
    the Barangay should be aware and be responsible also.

    Our
    country is suffering from this horrible situations that it shouldn’t be if the Pork
    Barrel was been used properly. It’s time for us to wake-up for the sake of our
    children future. And I think all of us should take responsibility to secure our
    Mother Nation in a simple way we can do big or small. God Bless Philippines.

To subscribe to the Philippine Daily Inquirer newspaper in the Philippines, call +63 2 896-6000 for Metro Manila and Metro Cebu or email your subscription request here.

Factual errors? Contact the Philippine Daily Inquirer's day desk. Believe this article violates journalistic ethics? Contact the Inquirer's Reader's Advocate. Or write The Readers' Advocate:

c/o Philippine Daily Inquirer Chino Roces Avenue corner Yague and Mascardo Streets, Makati City,Metro Manila, Philippines Or fax nos. +63 2 8974793 to 94

editors' picks

October 31, 2014

‘Wang-wang’ lives

advertisement
October 30, 2014

A heritage of dust

advertisement