There’s the Rub



I’m still thinking about what Pope Francis said the other day, about his being pained to see Catholic clergy driving flashy cars and his bidding them to use more modest ones. Seemingly a minor thing, it has not very minor implications.

He made the comment in an informal talk with seminarians. Catholics should “not be afraid of renewing some structures,” he said. “In Christian life, even in the life of the Church, there are ancient structures, transient structures: It is necessary to renew them!” Priests and nuns, he said, “should keep freshness and joy in their lives—there is no sadness in holiness.”

That’s when he got to the flashy cars. He wasn’t talking about superficial joy, he said, the kind that comes from getting the latest gadgets. “It hurts me when I see a priest or a nun with the latest-model car. You can’t do this. A car is necessary to do a lot of work, but please, choose a more humble one. If you like the fancy one, just think about how many children are dying of hunger in the world.”

It’s good advice. No, it’s brilliant advice.

At the very least, it’s brilliant advice for the Catholic Church, not least for the Philippine Catholic Church. In fact, it’s brilliant advice not just for the Catholic Church but for the other Christian churches, including the various sects that have sprouted in this country faster than mushrooms in the dark. Local Christian churches in particular validate themselves by displays of wealth and power, which often take, quite apart from displays of political clout, particularly during elections, the very physical one of grand, or grandiose, edifices. The Catholic Church has its cathedrals or basilicas with all their pomp and pompousness, the Iglesia ni Cristo has its splendorous spires, often strung out near each other (look at the ones on Commonwealth), that glow in the dark like Disneyland. Meant to extol the glory of God, they only succeed in extolling, particularly for the mesmerized or resentful poor, the glory of their officials.

The irony of it you see during Christmas when the birth of Christ is celebrated exuberantly and extravagantly in this country, except in Bangsamoro, forgetting that Christ was born in conditions that make “humble” sound commodious.

The one Mass I found deeply moving was a Misa de Gallo in Real, Quezon, ages ago during the pit of martial law. Bishop Julio Labayen had built a “Church of the Poor” there, shown quite literally in this particular place by a makeshift place of worship with an earthen floor to which the community had trooped. It was still dark, the air was nippy with breezes blowing from the sea, and the kids still had sleep in their eyes. But the folk had warmth in their hearts.

The Mass was in Tagalog, the priest took a morsel of rice and a sip of lambanog in lieu of bread and wine, and when he spoke of fishes the folk understood, being fishers themselves who depended on the sea for their life. The birthday celebrator was a Christ they knew, a fisher like one of them, the son of a carpenter like some of them, a poor person like all of them. He might have been sitting on one of the benches, talking to them, laughing with them. This was faith in its barest, simplest, crudest expressions. This was faith in its fullest, richest, deepest manifestations. Pope Francis had a point when he spoke about joy not being found in the lap of luxury.

At the very most, it’s brilliant advice for everyone, Christian or not, Catholic or not, believer or not. Pope Francis isn’t just warning against ostentation, he is warning against a set of values and attitudes, a particular mindset, or a way of life, that is making the world today more and more unlivable.

Chief of them consumerism. It’s worse today than yesterday. A failing global economy isn’t making people want less, it’s making people want more, with governments themselves urging consumers to buy more to bail out sinking economies. Of course the plethora of goods spawned by the digital revolution is epic enticement of itself. At no time has the Rolling Stones’ song, “I Can’t Get No Satisfaction,” been more apt than today. You can’t do without the latest cell phone. You can’t do without the latest tablet. You can’t do without the latest HDTV. And you can’t get no satisfaction.

The only time I saw a check to this on a large scale in this country was a lifetime ago during the halcyon days of activism. The change in values and attitudes, mindset and way of life in the campuses in particular was sweeping. Overnight, the culture in schools turned from cars and status symbols to rally and revolution—not just in the “university belt” but in the elite schools. Overnight, burgis was out and masa was in. Overnight, pursuing a career was selfish, serving the people was heroic. Overnight, wanting more and more possessions was laughable, making more and more sacrifices was admirable. Overnight, luxury sucked, many children were dying of hunger in the country. Overnight, simplicity commended itself, there was joy to be found in it.

You wonder when a phenomenon like that will strike again.

Who knows? Maybe people like Pope Francis, Chito Tagle, Tony Meloto, who have walked with the poor, who have talked with the poor, who have devoted their lives to trying to make the poor less poor—and the rich less poor in spirit—can help kick it in. It is certainly no small irony that Pope Francis has commended several people for sainthood, a chief criterion for which being that one has performed a miracle. I don’t know that Pope Francis himself will eventually qualify as one, but he has opened the eyes of people, faithful and faithless alike, to a lot of things that have always been right before them.

That is no mean miracle.

Get Inquirer updates while on the go, add us on these apps:

Inquirer Viber

Disclaimer: The comments uploaded on this site do not necessarily represent or reflect the views of management and owner of We reserve the right to exclude comments that we deem to be inconsistent with our editorial standards.

  • syano

    CDQ, you were once consistent but seems to maintain a double standard when the present dispensation came into power. You criticize the Catholic church and other Christian churches for ostentatious display of wealth but they are only the churches of their Filipino members.
    The President, on the other hand, is the president of all Filipinos.

    • tadasolo

      Ah good question!!! Religion preaches morality without being accountable while the president or any politician is. Have you seen a bishop nor religious head voted out due to non performance of their duties and found to be immoral in their actions? The problem is the religious order tend to protect and police themselves.

  • RyanE

    I guess the evolution of the church is quite extraordinary.. from executioner of witches and heretics to stockholder of Philex mining and user of luxury vehicles gifted by its politician-patrons.

  • el_latigo

    And these Damasings are the ones who love to pontificate about the so-called evils of the RH Bill deliberately omitting the issues and burden of feeding the poverty-stricken children that it will beget. Better if these so-called “good” bishops will help in rearing them and in keeping these poor kids’ body and souls together. But not a chance. They would rather stay in their palaces scratching their balls and meanwhile pass on the blame to the gov’t for not giving these poor kids’ mostly irresponsible parents jobs, homes, food on the table, etc. They who are partly if not mostly to blame for the runaway population growth this 3rd world country has to contend with, what can a right thinking Filipino say?

  • WeAry_Bat

    When I saw garbage floating in an area of sea I wouldn’t expect to be there, things slowly started to connect. It was like the youngblood article where the college student’s mind was stunned out of its bony cage when the writer saw a cat beside a dead fellow cat’s face in the garbage. Maybe it was the animal equivalent of sorrow or empathy.

    It is taking years but it is like the movie about four people in different parts of the world who were somehow connected by a single event.

    In elementary and high school, the sisters told us about living the humble life. Not to take into the materialism flooding into the country through TV and advertisements. It was the 70s, it was the heydey of TV ads becoming popular, of happiness linked to buying this product. Gee, my shampoo smells terrific.

    Then the soaring prices came, then the seeming uncertainty if the city will fall into a daily and nightly concert of gun fire with the chorus of a grenade.

    Here is the now, the most battered element in our lives is actually the environment. With every fanciful desire fanned by buy buy buy consummated in a purchase of the want, a small scratch is made in the already gaping hole of a tree trunk from a quadrillion of such strikes.

    Will the tree ever heal? Yes, when mankind has long been gone. Nature has a flair for equilibrium, be it now or a hundred years after our self-induced extinction.

    Being practical in buying is not just for the budget, but for the future.

    • Descarte5E

      In the event of nuclear holocaust that will wipe out the whole of mankind and all macro-living organism, nature will recover and grass and plants will sprout again. Living organisms will survive in as much as the planet’s carrying capacity can accomodate them. We live in finite planet with finite resources and there will come a time that all the resources of the earth will be depleted unless we became prudent in our consumption that will allow nature to recover from time to time. Rio Summit on Sustainability. We must take it seriously. Live simple. Live as to necessity.

  • Jao Romero

    the world is in a fork in the road right now. consumerism is needed if we want to avoid the economy crashing. ppl will have to choose. should we allow capitalism to continue or should we look for a better, saner way of living?

  • Descarte5E

    Sabi nga po sa bibliya, sa Mateo: Mas madali makapasok ang kamelyo sa butas ng karayom kaysa sa isang mayaman na makapasok sa kaharian ng langit.

To subscribe to the Philippine Daily Inquirer newspaper in the Philippines, call +63 2 896-6000 for Metro Manila and Metro Cebu or email your subscription request here.

Factual errors? Contact the Philippine Daily Inquirer's day desk. Believe this article violates journalistic ethics? Contact the Inquirer's Reader's Advocate. Or write The Readers' Advocate:

c/o Philippine Daily Inquirer Chino Roces Avenue corner Yague and Mascardo Streets, Makati City,Metro Manila, Philippines Or fax nos. +63 2 8974793 to 94


editors' picks

April 19, 2015

It’s Visit PH Year