At Large

‘Kapit sa patalim’



In contrast to other Filipino families whose members are in peril—families of OFWs in distress, kidnapped workers, or those in prison and facing trial—the family of the unnamed Filipino woman and her male first cousin have chosen to keep quiet and have avoided most media. The woman was recently executed by Chinese authorities on drug trafficking charges while her cousin has received a deferred sentence. But instead of tearful interviews, the public has at best heard only second-hand reports.

Even the family’s neighbors, approached by an Inquirer reporter in their own neighborhood, chose to be discreet, saying that, beyond sharing the chocolates brought home by the woman as  pasalubong  (homecoming gifts), her survivors kept their own counsel and rarely mingled with them.

Of course, we can understand the family’s silence. There is little to be proud of in their daughter’s case, and the fact that it involved drug trafficking took away much of the sympathy factor. And it isn’t as if she was a naïve novice traveler supposedly entrapped and lured by a Nigerian drug ring into bringing heroin into China. She was allegedly on her 18th trip to China since being recruited in 2007, earning between $3,000 and $4,000 each trip, a factor which surely played a huge role in her risk-taking.

Families of other drug mules have used the excuse of “poverty” to explain away the crime. But there are millions of Filipinos living below the poverty line and they have not had the opportunity or inclination to pack heroin in their luggage and brave the scrutiny of the Chinese. Any traveler to China and many other countries knows—as stated in travel documents—that drug trafficking is punishable by death. Sure brings an entirely new spin on “kapit  sa  patalim,” or clinging to a knife’s edge, meaning willingness to risk death or injury despite knowing the dangers.

* * *

Overseas workers’ groups and activist organizations lost no time denouncing the government’s supposed inaction and indifference to the executed drug mule’s case.

But as the Department of Foreign Affairs explained, the moment it heard about her arrest, it provided a lawyer for her and followed up the investigation and trial. Last week, it expedited the visit of the woman’s mother and son to the prison where the woman was held.

And what more could our top officials do?

P-Noy wrote a letter of appeal, in addition to verbal pleas for “clemency” for the woman. Vice President Jojo Binay was all set to travel to China to present the President’s letter to Chinese officials until he was advised that the timing for the trip would be unfortunate.

How much lower should our officials bow and scrape to save the life of someone who thought nothing of endangering her life to earn tremendous profits? What else do our officials have to do just to placate public opinion and prove their concern for a compatriot? And when will we stop subjecting national dignity to any more humiliation when our own people think nothing of staking everything for a quick buck?

* * *

There are exceptions, of course. And every Filipino abroad—with papers or without—deserves assistance and support when he or she runs afoul of lascivious employers, criminal syndicates, even local authorities.

And let’s add to the list smarmy Filipino representatives, paid by our government to assist our country folk, who use their positions to exploit oppressed workers, including those who have fled their employers and are in desperate straits. These government employees are to me the lowest of the low, exploiting the desperation and need of our “modern heroes” to satisfy their own base desires, including that of making a profit off the workers.

It’s not enough for the DFA and the Department of Labor and Employment, especially its agencies charged with managing labor export, to simply recall the erring officials and subject them to interrogation and investigation. If found guilty, they should be treated and punished as criminals, deserving the full panoply of penalties, including jail time.

Perhaps our officials should stop bending over backward to save the necks of those who have been found guilty by the courts of serious crimes—that is, beyond the basic duty to provide legal counsel and support. Instead, all that attention, time and money should be spent helping Filipinos who have been victimized in foreign countries without proper counsel or even knowing their rights. And we can start by recalling accused Filipino officials and punishing them after they have been found guilty.

* * *

Still, the basic warning of the DFA has to be heeded. Those tempted by so-called “easy money” to traffic in drugs should be made aware that doing so is punishable by death and jail time.

As the DFA spokesperson, Ambassador Raul Hernandez, declared: “Drug trafficking is a criminal act in the Philippines and all over the world. The life of every Filipino is valuable and we pray that this is the last time that a tragedy like this befalls any of our countrymen.”

If the fate of our unnamed kababayan—along with three others executed in China in 2011—is not enough of a lesson, then perhaps the collective shrug of a disgusted Filipino public the next time another Pinoy faces death due to drug charges would be enough of a deterrent.

Then again, our government should itself show a renewed resolve to end the illicit drug trade once and for all. As radio commentators point out, while Pinoy drug traffickers are put to death in China, in the Philippines Chinese drug lords and manufacturers are arrested and then somehow are allowed to go scot-free.

Maybe that’s why Filipino travelers themselves don’t take warnings against drug trafficking all that seriously.

Get Inquirer updates while on the go, add us on these apps:

Inquirer Viber

Disclaimer: The comments uploaded on this site do not necessarily represent or reflect the views of management and owner of We reserve the right to exclude comments that we deem to be inconsistent with our editorial standards.

  • cato_the_younger

    Filipinos who choose to engage in criminal activities anywhere around the world have no right – I repeat, no right – to feel aggrieved and expect the PH government to get them out of the mess they have put themselves into if they are get caught. I am extremely sick of people using poverty as an excuse to commit crimes. The world is full of poor people and most choose not to engage in it. If she’s on her 18th trip and she had been bringing in 3 or 4 thousand dollars, she can’t even justify it using poverty anymore – it’s just plain greed. Easy money.

  • brunogiordano

    Lahat ng tao ay CITIZEN of the WORLD.

    Kung ang isang tao ay nagkasala ng isang generally accepted crime, siya ay dapat lang maparusahan ayon sa batas.

  • gilbs72

    Droga ay salot sa sangkatauhan. Walang borders ang konsyensya pagdating sa ganitong kasalanan. Hayop lang ang dapat ituring sa pagsusulong ng droga kapalit ng salapi. Di natin malalaman ang salot na gagawin ng mga naipuslit na droga (yung di nauli). Malamang na mas marami pa’ng kamatayan ang idinulot ng mga nauna na’ng napuslit. Sa atin lang, ilang tao ang pinapatay na walang awa ng mga lulong sa droga? Mabuti na’ng putulin ng lipunan ang iilang masama kapalit ng pagtanggol sa maraming inosenteng tao.

    • Eustaquio Joven

      Ito ang maedalas makaligtaang banggitin sa maraming mga forum, at sa kolum na ito. Ito ang mas dapat na bigyang diin, kaysa takot na mahuli at mabigti. Ang parusa ay katapat ng perwisyong idinulot.

  • juan_liwanag

    Sa Pilipinas, kahit na convict na for drug trafficking nakakalaya pa, meron pa ngang na re-elect sa Kongreso. Kaya tama ang obserbasyon mo na hindi siniseryoso ng mga Pilipino ang problemang ito. Dapat talaga ay ibalik ang parusang bitay sa Pilipinas upang mabawasan ang salot ng lipunan. Yun namang problema ng mga OFWs, dapat ay suriing mabuti at hindi parang blanket na sinasabing kasalanan lahat ng mga tiga gobyerno. Marami sa mga may problemang OFWs ay kagaya nitong drug-mule na na execute. Huwag tayong basta naniniwala sa sabi-sabi. Kailangan ng masusing imbestigasyon para lumabas ang totoo.

    • Luthmar

      Drug mules are not OFWs. They have decent jobs. They work so hard for their money.

  • Jose EJ Flores

    “Kapit sa patalim” must never be accepted as an excuse for committing crimes. The simplest of these is the “trabaho lang” alibi of drivers of public utility vehicles to violate traffic rules is almost condoned by our citizens who are opting to bare the inconvenience caused by these drivers. Moral relativism (accepting what is wrong because majority is already permitting it) is slowly eating up the moral ascendancy of our nation just because we never had the moral and political will to discipline our citizens. We are already known as a nation of citizens with soft hearts, easily forgiving because we are easily forgetting. Where are we headed?

    • Ncarreonjr

      Short memory or stupidity?

    • Luthmar

      We are headed to the gutters, sad to say.

  • AllinLawisFair

    Eighteenth trip to China since being recruited in 2007, earning between $3,000 and $4,000 each trip?

    That’s a lot of money for such a seemingly easy job.

    No wonder many are lured to take the risk despite the fact that a few have been captured and executed.


  • generalproblem

    hindi po ang kahirapan ng dahilan bakit sila nawiwili na maging drug mule. ang mga pinoy po kasi lalo na yung mahirap ay nagiging tamad dahil sinasabi nga nila na mahirap sila at kasalanan ng gobyerno kung bakit sila mahirap. ang solusyon eradicate poverty patayin lahat ng mahirap

    • Luthmar

      Sobra ka naman, hindi na makatwiran ang comments mo.

  • tra6Gpeche

    Hindi katuwiran ang gumawa nang labag sa batas o gumawa nang masama dahil sa kahirapan. Hindi rin makatuwiran na makialam at tumulong ang gobyerno sa isang tao na alam na mali at masama ang kanyang ginagawa. Ang pagkonsenti sa masama ay magbibigay nang lakas ng loob at makahihikayat sa iba upang gumawa ng kasamaan. Dumami ang mga iligal na iskwaters dahil sa pagtulong at pag-ayon nang mga pulitiko at nang namamahala ng lunsod at bayan sa gawaing labag sa batas at kasamaang idinudulot ng mga iskwaters. Ganoon din ang mangyayari sa mga nagpupuslit nang ipinagbabawal na gamot. Parusahan ang nagkasala sa batas nang walang kinikilingan upang hindi pamarisan o tularan. Kapag hindi, lalong dadami ang kriminal na parang mga kabuti at marami sa atin ay mapipinsala at mapapahamak. Tandaan na nasa huli ang pagsisisi at hindi na maibabalik ang nakaraan!

  • brunogiordano

    “….then perhaps the collective shrug of a disgusted Filipino public the next time another Pinoy faces death due to drug charges would be enough of a deterrent.”


    Ito ang nararapat na reaction ng Filipino public sa sino man bibitayin sa salang drug trafficking.

  • clanwolf

    As I keep saying. Lets mandate every unemployed idiot with no visible means of self-support and a general community nuisance to be sterilized. Let’s start with all the prisoners in Muntinlupa. Anyone who volunteers to be neutered or vasectomized gets 1/4 of his sentence commuted.

To subscribe to the Philippine Daily Inquirer newspaper in the Philippines, call +63 2 896-6000 for Metro Manila and Metro Cebu or email your subscription request here.

Factual errors? Contact the Philippine Daily Inquirer's day desk. Believe this article violates journalistic ethics? Contact the Inquirer's Reader's Advocate. Or write The Readers' Advocate:

c/o Philippine Daily Inquirer Chino Roces Avenue corner Yague and Mascardo Streets, Makati City,Metro Manila, Philippines Or fax nos. +63 2 8974793 to 94


editors' picks

May 27, 2015

Shades of Sarah

May 26, 2015

Reason prevails