There’s the Rub

Bullies and coercers

A+
A
A-

The good news is that the United States has spoken out against China’s belligerence. Danny Russel, tapped to become the next assistant secretary for East Asian and Pacific Affairs, lambasted China for “coercion and bullying” in the China Sea region and said it was “unacceptable” for it to demand only bilateral talks with claimants of the disputed territories. He affirmed US support for the efforts of Southeast Asian nations to negotiate as a bloc, an initiative the Philippines has embarked on.

“I will do everything in my power to try to lower the temperature, push claimants, including China, into a diplomatic track and continue to warn them that the region in which China will flourish is a region of law, a region of order and a region of respect for neighbors.”

It’s a welcome statement, one that helps to internationalize the issue. Indeed, one that helps the Southeast Asian countries, with the exception of Cambodia which is only too willing to do China’s bidding, mount a common front against China. True enough, the Middle Kingdom has been engaged in coercing and bullying its Southeast and East Asian neighbors and can do with being stopped dead in its tracks by world condemnation. We need all the help we can get, and if the United States is willing to go out on a limb here, we’ll take it wholeheartedly.

The willingness to go out on a limb comes from the fact that the United States is currently locked in a love-hate relationship with China, with love being more in the agenda of late. The Economist in its June 8-14 issue had this for its main story, depicting in its cover the American and Chinese leaders in “Brokeback Mountain” poses. Its title went: “The Summit: Starring Barack Obama and Xi Jinping.” With the blurbs: “He stole his heart (and then his intellectual property)” and “‘Team America’ meets ‘Kung Fu Panda’.”

The hate owes to China becoming a growing power, which has American and Chinese hawks warning of an eventual military confrontation between the two. The love owes to the doves trying to prevent such a pass, and indeed proposing that cooperation between the two countries should immensely benefit both. The bilateral summit between Obama and Xi earlier this month was meant to push the latter idea.

Russel’s statement comes amid that context. Of course he’s not exactly high up in the bureaucratic ladder, but his words do carry weight, his office being directly in charge of these affairs. Of course too, the United States has been known to say one thing and do another, condemning Tiananmen and various human rights abuses in China while its businesses push and shove to gain a foothold into the coveted Chinese market. Russel’s statements look more like an attempt to score brownie points with the beleaguered Southeast Asian nations than anything else. It’s part of the game superpowers play.

The bad news is that these statements may spark more hilarity than comfort in the hearts and minds of these nations. The United States isn’t exactly the most credible entity to say those things, or it is credible only in the sense that it takes a thief to recognize a thief, or it takes a thief to catch a thief.

One of the Southeast Asian nations is Vietnam, a country that may not thoroughly appreciate America’s proffered role of nemesis of coercers and bullies. Not too long ago, at least as the Vietnamese memory goes, which is unlike the Filipino one, aided in no small way by nearly every Vietnamese family losing a member during the War, the United States was busy torching Vietnam’s forests with napalm. A thing that did not just raze down the trees, thereby leaving the Vietcong with no cover to hide under, but peeled off the skin of men, women, and children, quite apart from those of the guerrillas and wild animals, thereby giving to know horrible deaths. Coercing and bullying are benign words to describe that atrocity.

The reason for it was to give the Vietnamese freedom and progress, both of which they’ve had, quite apart from pride and dignity, after they kicked the coercers and bullies out. Indeed, the reason for it was to prevent China from spreading communism from Vietnam to the rest of Southeast Asia, called the domino theory, which never happened long after the Vietcong won in 1975. What happened in fact is that Vietnam is now locked in enmity with China. To this day, the United States has not apologized to the Vietnamese.

Just as well, it wasn’t too long ago—only 10 years last March in fact—when the United States shocked and awed the Iraqi population into submission with smart bombs that smartly killed far more, including children, than those in 9/11. It shocked and awed the world as well not just for the murderousness of the attacks but for the willingness of the United States, under the leadership of the demented Dubya, to defy the United Nations and mount the invasion on the grounds that Saddam Hussein possessed weapons of mass destruction. Naturally, they were never found. They never existed.

To call the Iraq invasion coercion and bullying is to call the Holocaust an exercise in lack of restraint.

The point is simple: China is a threat. It is growing and flexing its muscles. We need all the help we can get to push it back, not least from America. If Vietnam can welcome such a support, all of us can. But we need to exercise discernment too, we need to exercise shrewdness too. It’s one thing to welcome that support, it’s another to sing the praises of that particular supporter. A thing that particularly applies to us, believing as we do that the one country to have subjugated us and robbed us of our pride and dignity is our eternal patron and friend. We do need to affirm that our region is a region of law, a region of order, and a region of respect for neighbors. But that doesn’t just apply to China.

That applies to every bully and coercer.

Disclaimer: The comments uploaded on this site do not necessarily represent or reflect the views of management and owner of INQUIRER.net. We reserve the right to exclude comments that we deem to be inconsistent with our editorial standards.

  • Fulpol

    Chinese: “we should stop bullying the Hobbits now.. the US just took our toying with the Hobbits seriously”.. “they might send their Avengers”..

    “we should now focus on employing our trojan horses”..

    ako ay nakahahalata na ha…

  • $31552910

    The Philippines has to worry more about the next-door bully that is currently breathing down its neck. To enhance its security and counter new security challenges, the Philippines must broaden its strategic partnerships with other major powers, like Japan, India, Russia, Israel, and South Korea and acquire military assets and technology from those countries. There is no need for the Philippines to sacrifice its own sovereignty and strategic interests by allowing some foreign power to have military bases or military presence in its territory to confront the regional bully. The West Philippine Sea (South China Sea) is wide enough to conduct naval exercises and submarine patrols to ensure peace and stability in the region.

    • tadasolo

      The problem with your theory is you are assuming the countries you mentioned will be interested in a strategic partnership for the simple reason we do not bring nothing to bear on the table. These countries have very strong and credible defensive and offensive capabilities and we don’t. China is spending 200 billion dollars on its forces while the USA Is spending 600 billion e essentially drawfing our defense spending of 3 billion dollars which is enough to pay its personnel without anything credible. Come to think of it, our forces cannot even bring to bear and defeat a ragtag army of communist and moros and th e recent encounters which are so one sided are nothing to be proud off. Let us all be realistic. The real policy we should embraced is engaged and embrace both positions of the Chinese and American to open the sea lanes for unimpeded commerce and request any moratorium of tit for tat and prevent any mineral exploitation of these islands. Our current position is so weak and no nation will come to our rescue for the simple fact that China with its 7 trillion dollar economy growing at 8% (560 billion dollar growth) bigger than our economy of 250 billion dollars is no match. We may get sympathetic support but that is all there is. Americas strategic interest lies and is anchored by the countries of Japan and Korea with their robust defense and offensive capabilities. They are looking at India to provide them a room to maneuver in the India ocean as well the middle east. China is smart enough not provoke its neighbors by deliberately sending forces masquerading as civilians and will soon overwhelm whatever we can provide due to our lack in resources. Our value as a strategic partner has been non existent since we kick the Americans out. We need to find value in our position in those islands in terms of realpolitik and whether their value includes going against the chinese which we will lose and its accompanying lost economic lost opportunities. The Vietnamese President recently visited China and they cannot ignore the necessary engagement with the Chinese and the immense economic opportunities available by talking to them instead of our confrontational policy of engaging the chinese tit for tat in the open seas

      • kayanatwo

        24jun13

        @tadasolo:disqus , i second the motion your position.. except russia, all of those countries mentioned by “rf reemont” received billions of dollars in military aide or some form of assistance for military research and development plus socio-economic aide.

        american with their divided political ideologies and sagging economy is still the number one provider of military aide and financial assistance to the emerging developing and 3rd nations.

        just imagine the trillions of dollar saving if the united states cut all her military aide and financial assistance to the 3rd world countries. the US economy can get her economic woes solved in a wink of an eye.

  • Micashan

    it’s all about economic power , the trappings as well as the cloak and dagger stuff that come with it.
    America– did us serious damage when after ww2 enacted a serious land reform in japan and taiwan but did the reverse here. Swathes of land were handed over to a select few (the sugarcane haciendas) and that became the foundation for the inequitable economic development. PH could look at China straight in the eye if it were not an economic laggard. PH was a pawn in the Spanish American war and was just a convenient ally in the Pacific campaign during the war.

  • $31552910

    The presence of US nuclear-powered attack submarines, Aegis-equipped warships, an aircraft carrier or two, and reconnaissance aircrafts patrolling the West Philippine Sea (South China Sea) is more than enough to deter Chinese aggression. The island chain that extends from the Ryuku Islands, Taiwan, and the Philippines, which China faces towards the Pacific Ocean, has kept China bottled in. China’s nine-dash line territorial claim has been described as the biggest territorial grab since WW2. It is a serious challenge to international law. It is a threat to freedom of navigation. The Philippines occupies a strategic location. Its proximity to the Luzon Strait and the maritime territories in Kalayaan (Spratly) Islands and Panatag (Scarborough) Shoal gives the Philippines a strategic advantage. To further secure its vast maritime territories, the Philippines has to acquire its own deterrent capabilities that will make it unacceptably costly for China to attack or bully the Philippines. The Philippines can acquire military assets and technology from various countries and even develop some of its own.

To subscribe to the Philippine Daily Inquirer newspaper in the Philippines, call +63 2 896-6000 for Metro Manila and Metro Cebu or email your subscription request here.

Factual errors? Contact the Philippine Daily Inquirer's day desk. Believe this article violates journalistic ethics? Contact the Inquirer's Reader's Advocate. Or write The Readers' Advocate:

c/o Philippine Daily Inquirer Chino Roces Avenue corner Yague and Mascardo Streets, Makati City,Metro Manila, Philippines Or fax nos. +63 2 8974793 to 94

editors' picks

October 31, 2014

‘Wang-wang’ lives

advertisement
October 30, 2014

A heritage of dust

advertisement