As I See It

Another case of land-grabbing by QC government


Hhere is another case of the government being involved in land-grabbing, this time the Quezon City government, which is notorious for this abuse. The case is similar to that of the Manila Seedling Bank Foundation (MSBF). The QC government tried to seize MSBF’s 7-hectare lot on Quezon Avenue and Agham Road, allegedly for real estate tax delinquency, but was rebuffed by the courts.

In this case, a house and lot in Corinthian Gardens worth at least P10 million was sold at a public auction for a tax delinquency of only P173,505.25. A buyer, one Alexander Catolos who, according to a witness, is “friendly” with then QC Treasurer Vic Endriga and “a frequent and successful bidder at public auction sales conducted by the Office of the City Treasurer of Quezon City,” bought it for only P800,000.

After the owners of the property, which is registered in the name of Casa Mikael International Inc., filed a petition for the annulment of the auction sale and for the issuance of a temporary restraining order and a writ of preliminary injunction, Catolos allegedly offered to pay another P2 million if the owners would withdraw the petition and vacate the premises. The owners refused.

In its defense, the public respondents, the QC Treasurer and Register of Deeds, relied only on the “presumption of regularity” in their actions. Yet the evidence points to many irregularities, to wit:

“1. the absence of proof of publication of the final notice of delinquency;

“2. the absence of proof of mailing of the same;

“3. the highly irregular and suspicious claims of mailing and posting of notices on Sundays when government offices are closed for official business; and

“4. a disturbingly close relationship between Respondent Endriga and Respondent Catolos.”

The notices were sent to the wrong address and the owners never received any of these notices. The respondents presented no proof that the owners had received the notices. The owners’ first inkling that the house and lot had been sold at a public auction was a letter from a law firm, dated July 26, 2007, but received in August 2007, informing them of the execution of the Final Bill of Sale executed by QC Treasurer Endriga “in respect of a public auction sale on Sept. 15, 2005.” The letter also demanded that the owners vacate the premises and surrender the duplicate title to the property so a new title can be issued to Catolos. Imagine the shock of the owners.

“At no time did the [owners] receive by registered mail from the [Office of the QC Treasurer] any of the notices or statements enumerated in the Final Bill of Sale, specifically, the alleged (i) Statement of Delinquency; (ii) Final Notice of Delinquency; (iii) Warrant of Levy; and (iv) Notice of sale of Delinquent Real Property,” Casa Mikael said in its petition.

Furthermore, no notice of assessment was received by the owners. Neither did the Office of the QC Treasurer claim that it sent such a notice. In a decision, the Supreme Court cited the importance of an assessment: “An assessment contains not only a computation of tax liabilities but also a demand for payment within a prescribed period. It also signals the time when penalties and interests begin to accrue against the taxpayer. To enable the taxpayer to determine the remedies thereon, due process requires that it must be served on and received by the taxpayer.”

In a decision upheld by the high court in the case filed by the MSBF against the QC government, the regional trial court said:

“Inasmuch as no prior notice of assessment was served, there is no basis to collect any tax liability, no obligation arose on the part of the Plaintiff to pay the amount of real property taxes sought to be collected. Consequently, Plaintiff never became delinquent in the payment of said taxes to defendant Quezon City, and the latter never acquired any right to sell the subject properties in a public auction.”

For the same reason, Casa Mikael did not become delinquent in the payment of real estate taxes to the QC government and the latter never acquired any right to sell the property in a public auction.

Nevertheless, Catolos was able to obtain a writ of possession and, with the aid of the QC Sheriff, some city policemen, and about 40 watch-your-car boys around QC Hall, the residents of the property, Ruby Coyiuto and her young child, were forcibly thrown out of the house with their small possessions.

In its decision of Sept. 9, 2011, Branch 100 of the QC RTC issued a writ of preliminary injunction in favor of Casa Mikael. It said: “To continue to allow Casa Mikael to be deprived of the possession of the subject property while its Petition for Relief from Judgment is being heard and tried is a violation of its right (to due process).”

Catolos filed a motion for reconsideration and for the disqualification and voluntary inhibition of Judge Marie Christine A. Jacob from the case.

In her decision on that case, Judge Jacob said: “This Court is totally appalled by Catolos’ utterly baseless and malicious and debasing allegations to rationalize his filing of Motion for Voluntary Inhibition. His penchant to distort facts, draw groundless conclusions and impute impropriety where none exists to pursue his personal ends is revealing of the reason why this legal row came about in the first place…

“…Fully aware that Catolos’ tactic in filing an unfounded motion for disqualification of the undersigned is a means of forum shopping for a more friendly judge, the undersigned is also mindful of the fact that if she holds on to this case, it may be misconstrued as an overriding desire to keep the same.”

Jacob thus inhibited herself from the case.

The case is now with another judge. We will watch how he/she conducts and rules on this case.

Follow Us

Follow us on Facebook Follow on Twitter Follow on Twitter

More from this Column:

Other Stories:

No related posts found!

Recent Stories:

Complete stories on our Digital Edition newsstand for tablets, netbooks and mobile phones; 14-issue free trial. About to step out? Get breaking alerts on your mobile.phone. Text ON INQ BREAKING to 4467, for Globe, Smart and Sun subscribers in the Philippines.

Short URL: http://opinion.inquirer.net/?p=37156

Tags: corinthian gardens , land-grabbing , neal h. cruz , qc government , vic endriga

Copyright © 2014, .
To subscribe to the Philippine Daily Inquirer newspaper in the Philippines, call +63 2 896-6000 for Metro Manila and Metro Cebu or email your subscription request here.
Factual errors? Contact the Philippine Daily Inquirer's day desk. Believe this article violates journalistic ethics? Contact the Inquirer's Reader's Advocate. Or write The Readers' Advocate:
c/o Philippine Daily Inquirer Chino Roces Avenue corner Yague and Mascardo Streets, Makati City, Metro Manila, Philippines Or fax nos. +63 2 8974793 to 94


  • Tens of thousands travel by sea this Holy Week
  • Police: Dad smothered toddler to play video game
  • 7 killed in shooting in China-Vietnam border
  • Chinese trade group to mediate shoe factory strike
  • Malaysia, Australia in deal on black box custody–report
  • Sports

  • Pacquiao shorts in Bradley fight sold for P1.7M in LA auction
  • Ryu pitches Dodgers past Giants
  • Alonso sets the pace in Chinese GP practice
  • Heat seek Three-peat but Spurs, Pacers top seeds
  • Can Spurs get back at Heat? Can they survive West?
  • Lifestyle

  • Levine designs womenswear with help from fiancee
  • Gabriel Garcia Marquez, Nobel laureate, dies at 87
  • Ford Mustang turns 50 atop Empire State Building
  • Pro visual artists, lensmen to judge Pagcor’s photo contest
  • ‘Labahita a la bacalao’
  • Entertainment

  • EXO postpones release of mini album ‘Overdose’
  • ‘X-men’ filmmaker slams ‘fabricated’ sex attack claims
  • Singer Chris Brown’s bodyguard on trial in DC
  • Whoopi Goldberg debuts as marijuana columnist
  • ‘X-men’ director accused of sex assault on teen boy
  • Business

  • Italy sells luxury state cars on eBay
  • Asian shares mostly up in quiet trade
  • Dollar up in Asia on US jobs data, Ukraine deal
  • Barbie doll has a problem
  • Oil prices mixed ahead of long Easter weekend
  • Technology

  • Netizens pay respects to Gabriel Garcia Marquez
  • Nokia recalls 30,000 chargers for Lumia 2520 tablet
  • Facebook rolls out ‘nearby friends’ feature
  • Netizens seethe over Aquino’s ‘sacrifice’ message
  • Filipinos #PrayForSouthKorea
  • Opinion

  • Editorial cartoon, April 17, 2014
  • A humbler Church
  • Deepest darkness
  • ‘Agnihotra’ for Earth’s health
  • It’s the Holy Week, time to think of others
  • Global Nation

  • DoH denies Filipino nurse no longer positive for MERS virus
  • WHO warns vs spread of MERS-Cov, urges vigilance in taking precautions
  • Last call for nominations to ’14 Presidential Awards
  • San Francisco business coalition slams proposed tax on sugary drinks
  • A ‘time-travel’ production of ‘Les Miserable’ at Stanford
  • Marketplace