To save women, newborns during childbirth
BOSTON — Tennis star Serena Williams’ harrowing story of life-threatening complications after her daughter’s birth reminds us that childbirth is potentially deadly for any woman or newborn. Williams suffered a pulmonary embolism — a blood clot in her lung. After advocating for herself, she received the lifesaving care she needed. Millions of women worldwide do not.
Yearly, more than 5.6 million women and newborns die during pregnancy, childbirth, or in the first month of life. Low-quality care during the 48 hours around childbirth, in particular, is one of the greatest contributors to birth-related suffering and death. These deaths shatter families and communities. And, compounding the tragedy, 99 percent of the maternal deaths and 80 percent of the newborn deaths can be prevented with the right care.
What kills women and newborns around childbirth? The biggest killers of women are hemorrhage, sepsis, obstructed labor, and eclampsia. For newborns, the main risks are asphyxia (difficulty in breathing), prematurity, and infection. How to assess, treat, and prevent these causes of death has been known for decades. In many cases, simple steps like washing hands, warming the baby with skin-to-skin care, or treating high blood pressure would make all the difference.
Globally, childbirth has shifted from the home to health facilities where a skilled clinician could provide safer care. This should mean better care and better outcomes. But in many places, encouraging women to deliver in health facilities, rather than at home, has not resulted in reduced mortality. In too many places, facilities are unable to provide even the most basic care—like monitoring a laboring woman’s blood pressure—and women face lack of privacy, unhygienic conditions, or even abuse by staff.
For the last three years, we ran BetterBirth, one of the world’s largest maternal-newborn health trials, in the Indian state of Uttar Pradesh to see if we could reduce deaths by improving the quality of care in frontline facilities. These facilities, where most local women give birth, each averaged 3-4 deliveries a day, most of which were conducted by nurses. In the average facility, we found that proper hand washing was completed in less than 1 percent of deliveries, and only 25 percent of women received the right medication to prevent postpartum bleeding. Overall, 11 of 18 essential birth practices were missing.
To improve performance and outcomes, we didn’t punish or fire staff. The problems typically stemmed from lack of organization and coordination to make certain that staff had the supplies, training, and supervision they needed. No method had been proved to make a large-scale difference. But we had a theory that coaching teams to implement key practices would help. We trained a group of nurses and doctors to coach birth attendants and managers to deliver the vital basics found in the World Health Organization’s Safe Childbirth Checklist: proper supplies and steps to prevent infection, identification and treatment of high blood pressure to prevent eclampsia, and appropriate medication to prevent hemorrhage.
The result was significant progress, but still not quite enough. We confirmed marked improvement in care. Birth attendants who had been performing just 7 of 18 known life-saving steps during childbirth now performed 13. We showed that it is possible to improve significantly the quality of care in low-resource settings. Yet the evidence showed that we needed to do more to achieve a large-scale reduction in mortality rates.
The effort can be difficult and discouraging. Effective health systems must be able to close nearly all gaps in care, including gaps in supplies and equipment, basic skills and capabilities, and communication and connections to higher-level health facilities for sick mothers and babies. The relationships between clinical leaders and frontline providers, and between providers and the families they serve, must be respectful and supportive. There are no shortcuts. This is true everywhere in the world, whether in Florida, where Williams delivered, or in Uttar Pradesh.
But, as we observed, while our basic checklist provided the targets for improvement and a tool for organizing and reminding people of key steps, more was needed to accelerate change, including financial resources, political will, and the dedication of leaders, providers, and the community to demand progress. Project Syndicate
* * *
Katherine Semrau is director of the Ariadne Labs BetterBirth Program, an assistant professor of medicine at Harvard Medical School, and an associate epidemiologist in the Division of Global Health Equity at Brigham and Women’s Hospital. Atul Gawande is executive director of Ariadne Labs, a professor at Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health, and a surgeon at Brigham and Women’s Hospital.
